How scoring works

Every report is scored on up to four signals, computed by checking claims against the real pages a report actually pulled from — never by asking the model to grade its own work. Here's what each one is actually measuring.

Five signals

Comparability

Whether these items should even be compared in the first place — how confident the model was that they genuinely share a category, combined with how evenly documented they turned out to be. Only shown on a direct comparison between two or more items; a single-subject profile has nothing to compare against.

Authority

How much a domain should be trusted for this specific topic — not a fixed reputation score. A hospital's site rates very differently for a medical question than for an unrelated one.

Source Matching

Whether independent evidence was actually found for a claim, checked against the pages a report really fetched — not what the model said it used, and not affected by whether it claimed a source at all.

Corroboration

How many independent domains, on average, back each claim — a stronger signal than Source Matching, since it measures agreement, not just existence. Independent sources can still all repeat the same error, so this is a measure of agreement, not proof of truth.

Reading the combinations

A single badge tells you one thing. A few combinations of them tell you something a single badge doesn't.

Source Matching: 0Corroboration: 0

Nothing here has any independent backing — either it was never searched, or it was searched and nothing turned up. Treat it as unverified either way.

Comparability: lowEverything else: high

The facts themselves are well-sourced. The caution is about the pairing — these items may not be a natural fit to compare, or one is far better documented than the other.

Source Matching: HighCorroboration: Low

Almost every claim has a real source, but rarely more than one. Single-sourced throughout — present, but not independently confirmed.

Source Matching: HighCorroboration: HighAuthority: Low

Multiple independent domains back these claims, but they may not be trusted for the subject. Several forums or general-interest sites agreeing doesn't carry the same weight as one topic specialist.

Not a guarantee

A grade is a confidence signal, not a guarantee. It tells you how much checking stands behind a claim, not that the claim is beyond question. That's deliberate: the point isn't to replace your judgment, it's to give you enough to exercise it quickly.